Colgate Roster
| # | DOB | Yr/Elig | HT | WT | POS | Bats | Throws | Hometown | High School |
| Benoit, Eric | 11/1996 | 4th / Sr | 5' 7" | 200 | | | | Worcester, MA | St. Peter Marian |
| Boquist, Cole INACTIVE | 04/1998 | 2nd / So | 5' 10" | 160 | | Right | Right | West Chester, PA | West Chester B. Reed Henderson |
| Freishtat, Nathaniel INACTIVE | 07/2000 | 1st / Fr | 6' 0" | 175 | | | | Washington, DC | Sidwell Friends School |
| Goodie, Caleb INACTIVE | 09/1997 | 4th / Sr | 5' 10" | 150 | | | | Hagerstown, MD | Saint James School |
| Griffin, DJ | 12/1998 | 2nd / So | 5' 9" | 156 | C / 3B | Right | Right | Bronx, NY | Fordham Preparatory School |
| Hallinan, Owen | 03/2000 | 1st / Fr | 5' 10" | 150 | OF / 3B | Left | Left | Studio City, CA | Harvard-Westlake School |
| 1 | Hughes, Keontré | 08/1999 | 2nd / So | 5' 11" | 165 | OF / FLEX | Right | Right | Fort Wayne, IN | Concordia Lutheran |
| Kaplan, Tyler | 04/2000 | 1st / Fr | 6' 0" | 185 | | | | New York, NY | Trinity School |
| Keeley, Jacob | 03/2000 | 1st / Fr | 5' 11" | 240 | 1B / 3B | Right | Right | Manchester-Shortsville, NY | Red Jacket |
| Lehmann, Webster | 03/2000 | 1st / Fr | 5' 8" | 125 | 2B / P | Right | Right | St. Paul, MN | St. Paul Academy |
| 6 | Marcus, Matthew | 12/1999 | 1st / Fr | 5' 10" | 160 | SS / 2B | Right | Right | Mamaroneck, NY | Mamaroneck |
| Tenner, Joey | 03/2000 | 1st / Fr | 6' 0" | 175 | 2B / 2B | Right | Right | Mamaroneck, NY | Rye Neck |
| 16 | Timothy, Sam | 02/1997 | 4th / Sr | 6' 0" | 160 | P / C | Switch | Right | Port Washington, NY | Schreiber |